Membership
Membership Retention Strategies: How to Improve Loyalty & Reduce Churn
Is your membership bucket leaking?
Membership retention strategy: In membership and subscription businesses, retention is often overlooked in favour of acquiring new members—but prioritising retention is crucial for achieving sustainable, long-term growth
Leading subscription companies know retention delivers superior ROI, a stronger community, and deeper member loyalty. Membership organisations can adopt similar retention strategies, leveraging data-driven insights and AI-enhanced approaches, to enhance their value proposition, improve engagement, and ultimately build a stable, thriving community.
Why membership retention matters more than acquisition
Research by the American Society of Association Executives (ASAE) shows the highest membership drop-off occurs within the first year, with organisations losing between 30-50% of new members. Conversely, Marketing General Incorporated (MGI) found that members who stay beyond three years are significantly more likely to remain long-term.
Fred Reichheld, a renowned loyalty expert, highlights the profitability of retention:
“A 5% improvement in customer retention can increase profitability by 25% to 85% depending on the industry.”
Membership models rely heavily on long-term relationships. High churn rates significantly impact sustainability by reducing revenue, trust, and credibility. Constant turnover indicates underlying engagement and value perception issues, which can be better understood and addressed through detailed data analysis and predictive analytics powered by AI.
The hidden cost of focusing only on acquisition
Bain & Company reports that increasing retention rates by just 5% can boost profits by 25% to 95%. Despite this, many organisations dedicate up to 70% of their marketing budget to acquisition (Harvard Business Review, 2020).
Acquiring new members is costly—up to 25 times more expensive than retaining existing ones. Yet, many membership organisations still allocate disproportionate budgets to acquisition.
Budgeting for membership retention & calculating ROI
Allocating a clear retention budget with measurable ROI metrics is crucial. Setting aside a specific retention spend per member allows organisations to proactively prioritise retention. Organisations can utilise data analytics and AI-driven tools to measure, predict, and track the effectiveness of their retention investments, demonstrating a clear correlation between spending and improved retention.
Leading subscription businesses such as Netflix, HubSpot, and Salesforce effectively balance their budgets, investing in personalised member experiences powered by data analytics and AI-driven insights. These companies utilise data to deeply understand member preferences and predict churn, allowing targeted retention efforts.
Effective onboarding to improve early member retention
The first year is critical for member retention. During this time, new members test their decision, assessing tangible benefits and value. Without immediate value, members frequently disengage.
Organisations should proactively track early member engagement using data analytics and AI tools to identify patterns of disengagement early, allowing targeted, predictive interventions:
- Targeted outreach – AI-driven personalised messages to re-engage low-interaction members.
- Check-in surveys – Analysing data from member feedback to identify and address barriers.
- Exclusive incentives – Data-informed personalised experiences designed to recapture interest.
A structured onboarding process should include:
- Clear introductions informed by member data.
- Frequent, AI-personalised communications.
- Celebrating member milestones based on member activity insights.
- Exclusive experiences tailored through predictive analytics for first-year members.
Retention doesn’t require huge budgets. Strategic, data-driven initiatives can reinforce belonging, creating lasting impacts and increasing long-term commitment.
Long-term engagement techniques for member loyalty
Beyond year one, retention focuses less on transactional value and more on cultivating loyalty. Members beyond the three-year mark typically exhibit stronger loyalty due to deeper brand connections.
Key long-term engagement strategies include:
- Ongoing AI-driven personalised communication and value-driven interactions informed by member behaviour data.
- Building community through targeted networking and peer-to-peer opportunities, identified through engagement data.
- Encouraging volunteerism, event participation, research contribution, and active feedback, driven by data analysis of member interests.
- Proactive renewal nurturing throughout the year, using predictive analytics to anticipate and address potential churn.
Segmenting efforts between onboarding and long-term loyalty, informed by continuous data analysis, deepens member commitment and ensures sustainable growth.
How Propeller Solutions can help Improve member retention
Propeller Solutions specialises in data-driven member engagement, AI-enhanced onboarding optimisation, and long-term retention strategies. We help organisations leverage data and AI tools to build stronger connections, foster loyalty, and achieve sustainable growth. Our tailored strategies empower your organisation to thrive in the competitive membership landscape.
Conclusion: Retention as your competitive advantage
Effective membership retention strategies deliver far more than cost savings—they build strong relationships, establish credibility, and cultivate a committed member community. By leveraging data analytics and AI tools, organisations focusing on retention not only stabilise their membership base but transform members into passionate advocates.
Ready to enhance your retention strategy and ensure sustainable growth? Partner with Propeller Solutions and plug the leaks in your membership bucket—because your success isn’t defined by the members you attract, but by the members you retain
With 30 years of experience in the membership sector, Mel has helped organisations understand their members, strengthen engagement, and drive sustainable growth. Her expertise combines traditional strategies with innovative technology, such as AI-driven analytics, to deliver deeper insights and more personalised member experiences. Mel’s focus is on building robust revenue streams while fostering lasting relationships. Through coaching and mentoring, she empowers teams with the skills, confidence, and tech-enabled approaches to develop practical, results-driven strategies. Collaboration is central to her approach—bringing together industry knowledge, fresh ideas, and cutting-edge technology to tackle challenges and unlock new opportunities.
Mel Sallis - Membership Strategist and Coach
If you would like to discuss your membership programme or are interested in coaching or mentoring for yourself or your team, please get in touch
Latest Articles...
How AI and Blue Ocean Strategy are Transforming Membership Organisations
Membership organisations are facing increasing competition and shifting member expectations. This blog explores how Blue Ocean Strategy and AI can help you innovate, personalise engagement, and create a culture ready for the future. Learn how to move beyond traditional models and build a truly indispensable membership offer.
How AI could transform the membership sector
AI is changing how membership organisations engage, support and retain their members.
This article explores practical ways AI can improve content, services and insight—plus how to overcome common barriers. Whether you’re curious or ready to act, now is the time to start your AI journey.
Global Membership Research
We’re inviting membership professionals and partners to share their insights in a major global survey exploring the future of membership organisations. Your input will help shape a clearer understanding of the challenges and opportunities facing our sector – and in return, you’ll receive a free report packed with valuable, practical insights.